Why Conservative Christians Should Vote for McCain

Posted by Katherine | July 24, 2008 – 2:16 pm
Pro-life protester in front of Supreme Court
[rev_bri / Flickr]

A lot of conservative Christians — who voted reliably for Bush in the last two elections — seem to be alienated and disappointed by McCain as their Republican option. Some, though, argue pragmatically that it’s in their long-term interest to support him.

Kara is a Christian who is “determined in prayer and honesty” (and fond of adjectives). She’s dumbfounded by evangelicals threatening to sit out the election. Kara feels it’s her “duty as a Christian and as an American citizen” to cast a vote because it will have an effect on issues important to her. (Hat tip to Ann Raber.)

I am not overly happy with Obama or McCain. But I must look beyond myself to the future here for a moment. What candidate is closer to the convictions I hold? What candidate will put into place or position what I stand for even if it won’t have any bearing on me? Let me go out on a limb and give you a personal example here. Abortion. Protecting the life of a child is important to me. […] So, what type of Supreme Court judge do I want? […] [O]ne who will protect the rights of a child. Who elects Supreme Court judges? The President.

[…] While the Presidency is temporary, they have the power to put people in power permanently. So why wouldn’t I vote? I might not be pleased today, but I must think ahead. To not vote would be a disaster. And to not vote on the grounds that I am a Christian would be even worse. I don’t want to be so spiritually minded that I am no earthly good. What does not voting do? It takes away your God given voice.

Michigan-based Will is a seminary student who writes a blog called Pro Life Evangelical. He’s “not a big McCain fan” either, but he’s still “supporting him strongly” for the same reasons as Kara: because he’s more likely to appoint a pro-life Supreme Court judge. Will has taken some flack for this stance and defends himself (thanks again, Ann Raber):

[V]oting for McCain is not a compromise of principle. I maintain my principles fully (I oppose abortion completely and in all cases) and I try to achieve those goals using imperfect tools (such as Reagan, Bush and McCain). You can be so principled about wanting to drive a nail into a 2×4 that when you can’t find a good hammer, you use a stone instead. Using the stone is not a compromise….it actually shows your dedication to the project.

Quite a different viewpoint from that of some conservative Christians who are turning their focus away from traditional issues and even politics altogether.


Sorry, comments for this entry are closed at this time.